HES Activity 1.4 Assessment


This activity contains numerous opportunities for formative assessment. First, see how students describe the global trend of temperature anomalies in step two. Next, see what explanations they provide when you ask them to predict how much arctic sea ice will be on Lake Superior in five years. Do they confidently make a prediction, or do they suggest that they cannot predict due to the variation in the graph? Finally, monitor how easily they are able to construct the trend line on the Lake Superior graph in step four. If they have trouble with either of these, you may want to revisit these steps before moving to the next Activity.


  • The method included in this activity represents just one of many ways to quickly find a trend in noisy data. If you have a preferred method you are more comfortable with, you might want to experiment with multiple methods in this activity.
  • If students are having trouble identifying a trend in the data, have them calculate an average of the stars on the left side of the graph and the stars on the right side, and then draw a line going through the two new averages. This should make the negative trend very clear.